To evaluate the feasibility and effectiveness of high flow nasal oxygen therapy in the treatment of hypoxemia after cardiac surgery by comparing with non-invasive positive pressure ventilation.
Meta-analysis of the Efficacy of Different Oxygen therapies in patients with Hypoxemia after cardiac surgery
WangYuanyuan1 JiaoYongning1 WangDongchang1 LiuLei2 ChenGang1
1The First Department of Respiratory Medicine the Third Hospital of Hebei Medical University Shijiazhuang050051 China 2DepartmentofCardiacSurgery theThird Hospital of HebeiMedicalUniversity Shijiazhuang050051 China
Corresponding author WangDongchang Email dongchangwang@hebmu.edu.cn
【Abstract】
Objective
To evaluate the feasibility and effectiveness of high flow nasal oxygen therapy in the treatment of hypoxemia after cardiac surgery by comparing with non-invasive positive pressure ventilation
Methods
The literatures from January 2000 to March 2023 were searched,including Pubmed, Medline ,Embase database ,CNKI ,China Medical Journal Full-text Database, Wanfang database, Corchrane library and secondary resources .
Results
A total of 11 trials involving 2107 patients were included. The results of meta-analysis showed that the reintubation rate in the high-flow oxygen therapy group was lower than that in the non-invasive positive pressure ventilation group (OR =0.37 95% CI 0 .25-0 .53) and the difference was statistically significant (Z =5 .35, P <0 .01).
The mortality (OR =1 .08 ,95% CI :0.68-1 .74 ),the rate of treatment failure( OR =0 .96 95% CI 0.73-1.28), and the length of ICU stay (OR =0.08 95% CI :-0.04-0.20 )between the two groups were not statistically significant ( Z values were 0.33., 0.25, and1. 28, respectively all P >0.05 )
Conclusions
Compared with non-invasive positive pressure ventilation, high-flow oxygen therapy has certain advantages in reintubation rate. However there were no significant differences in mortality ,treatment failure and length of hospital stay .The results suggest that the use of high-flow oxygen inhalation may become a new viable option for
Patients with hypoxemia after cardiac surgery
【Key words】
Hypoxia ;High flow nasal oxygen therapy; Non-invasive positive pressure ventilation;Respiratory support; Cardiac surgery
Fundprogram Hebei Medical Scientific Research Key Project Plan (20180467)
DOI: 10. 3760/ cma .j .cn131368-20230508-00284
—The end—